
Your Dental Practice Has Hundreds of Patients Who Haven’t Been Back. Do You Know Why?
Pull an inactive patient report from almost any established dental practice and the number can be surprising.
Hundreds of patients.
Sometimes thousands.
People who haven't been back in 18 months, two years, three years or longer.
The typical response is:
“We need to reactivate them.”
Yes.
But before you start sending texts, emails and postcards, I think there's a more important question.
Why did they leave?
Because if you don't know that, you're trying to bring patients back into the same practice they already decided not to return to.
Not Every Inactive Patient Is a Lost Patient
Some patients moved. Some passed away. Some changed jobs or insurance. Some went away to college.
Some had a financial situation change. Some simply forgot.
That's normal.
But that doesn't explain everyone.
There are also patients who couldn't get an appointment when they needed one.
Patients who called and never heard back.
Patients who became frustrated with billing.
Patients who didn't feel comfortable with a treatment recommendation.
Patients who had an interaction with someone on the team that didn't sit well.
Patients who felt like the practice had changed.
Patients who found another dentist that was closer, easier or more convenient.
And patients who gradually disappeared without anyone noticing.
Those are the patients I'd want to understand.
Here's What I Would Do
Instead of immediately launching another reactivation campaign, I'd pull a sample.
Maybe 50 patients who haven't returned in 18 to 24 months.
Then I’d actually look at them.
When was their last appointment?
Did they leave with unscheduled treatment?
Were they overdue for hygiene?
Did they cancel an appointment and never reschedule?
Did the practice try to contact them?
How many times?
Was there a billing issue?
Did something happen during their final few visits?
You won’t find every answer in the software.
That’s okay.
You’re looking for patterns.
You May Find Something You Weren’t Expecting
Imagine looking at 50 inactive patients and discovering that 17 of them had canceled a hygiene appointment and never rescheduled.
That’s interesting.
Or maybe 12 had diagnosed treatment sitting unscheduled.
Also interesting.
Or you notice that a surprising number disappeared during a period when the practice was short-staffed and phones weren’t being answered consistently.
Now you’re learning something.
The inactive patient report stops being a list of people to market to.
It becomes information about the practice.
I’d Also Call Some of Them
This is probably where I’d make everyone uncomfortable.
I’d pick up the phone.
Not with a sales script or saying, “We noticed you're overdue for your cleaning!”
I’d actually talk to them.
Something like:
“Hi Susan, this is Kathy from Dr. Smith’s office. We realized we haven’t seen you in a while and I wanted to check in. Is everything okay?”
Then listen.
Some people will say they moved.
OK.
Some will say they’ve been meaning to call.
Great.
Some may tell you they started going somewhere else.
That’s the conversation I’d be interested in.
I’d want to know why.
Not to argue or convince them they’re wrong.
To learn.
You might hear something you’ve never heard before.
Losing Existing Patients Is Expensive
Practices spend a lot of money trying to attract new patients.
Let’s say it costs $300 in marketing to acquire one.
If 20 existing patients quietly disappear every month, the practice would need to spend roughly $6,000 just to replace them.
Not to grow but to just to stay even.
And that’s before considering the treatment, hygiene, referrals and long-term value those patients would have generated.
Retention isn’t nearly as exciting as new-patient marketing.
Financially, though it is every bit as important.
Your New Patient Number Can Hide This
This is another number I think can fool dentists.
A practice gets 40 new patients this month.
Everyone feels good.
But what if 30 existing patients became inactive during the same period?
The practice didn’t really gain 40 patients.
Its active patient base grew by 10.
Totally different picture.
And if 45 patients quietly left?
The practice actually shrank while reporting 40 new patients.
That’s why looking only at new-patient counts doesn’t tell you whether the practice is truly growing.
Reactivation Is So Important
Absolutely contact inactive patients.
Some will come back.
And there are good systems that can make that process much easier.
But I wouldn’t stop there.
I’d use the information.
If patients are disappearing because they can’t get hygiene appointments, fix capacity.
If they’re disappearing after canceling, look at your rescheduling process.
If they’re leaving with unscheduled treatment, look at follow-up.
If they’re frustrated with communication, find out where it’s breaking down.
If nobody knows why they’re leaving, start paying attention.
Because sending another text saying:
“We miss your smile!”
doesn’t fix any of those things.
One Number I’d Start Tracking
I’d want to know how many active patients the practice has today.
Then I’d track it.
Is that number actually growing?
Because a practice can bring in a tremendous number of new patients and still struggle to grow if patients are quietly leaving through the back door.
Your inactive patient list may contain patients worth bringing back.
It may also contain something even more valuable:
The reasons they left.
If you'd like help figuring out where patients may be quietly slipping away in your practice, let's have a conversation.
Schedule here.