
Should Your Dental Practice Drop an Insurance Plan? Start With the Numbers.
I've had plenty of conversations with dentists who are fed up with insurance.
I get it.
They look at their full fee. Then they look at what they’re allowed to collect.
Meanwhile, payroll keeps going up. Supplies cost more. Lab bills cost more. Everything costs more.
Eventually the dentist says:
“Why am I accepting this plan?”
That’s a fair question.
But before dropping any insurance plan, I’d want to answer another one:
What is this plan actually worth to the practice?
That number is a lot more complicated than looking at the fee schedule.
Start With the Obvious Numbers
Let’s say one PPO represents $500,000 of annual production.
That’s could be pretty significant.
But what does $500,000 actually mean?
I’d want to know:
What would that dentistry have produced at your normal fees?
What were the contractual adjustments?
What did you actually collect?
How many active patients are associated with the plan?
How many appointments did those patients use?
What procedures were performed?
How many new patients did the plan actually bring into the practice?
Suppose that $500,000 would have been $650,000 at your normal fees.
That’s $150,000 in contractual adjustments.
Painful.
But I still wouldn’t make a decision because we’re missing part of the story.
How Much Dentistry Are Those Patients Buying Outside Their Coverage?
This is a number I think could completely change the analysis for some practices and one that may be overlooked.
Let’s say you place implants.
A patient originally chooses your practice because you’re in-network.
They come in for hygiene for several years.
Then they need an implant.
Depending on their benefits, much of that treatment may be patient-paid.
Maybe they eventually do another implant.
Or whitening.
Or cosmetic dentistry.
Or treatment after they’ve exhausted their annual maximum.
If you’re evaluating that patient only by what the insurance company reimbursed, you're not looking at the whole relationship.
So I’d want another number:
How much total production is coming from these patients beyond what the plan is actually paying for?
That could include:
implants
cosmetic dentistry
whitening
elective procedures
upgrades
treatment beyond annual maximums
other non-covered or partially covered services
For some practices, that number may be relatively small.
For others, particularly practices doing a lot of implants or comprehensive dentistry, it could be substantial.
You need to know.
Then There Are the Patients They Bring With Them
This is harder to measure, but I wouldn’t ignore it.
A patient finds you because you’re on their insurance plan.
They like you.
Their spouse becomes a patient.
Then their kids.
A few years later, they refer a neighbor.
The insurance company didn’t technically send you four patients.
It sent you one.
But that one relationship created four.
What are those additional patients worth?
You may never be able to calculate this perfectly.
That’s okay.
The fact that something is difficult to measure doesn’t mean it has no value.
Now Let’s Talk About Capacity
This is where the exact same insurance plan can be valuable to one practice and a problem for another.
Imagine you’re booked solid.
Hygiene is booked five months out.
New patients are waiting weeks.
The doctor’s schedule is packed.
At that point, every appointment has value.
If a large amount of your available capacity is being consumed by heavily discounted dentistry, I’d want to know what could happen if some of that capacity were available for better-reimbursed treatment.
Now imagine another practice.
Hygiene has openings.
The doctor has holes in the schedule.
New-patient flow isn’t strong.
That practice may be far better off filling those appointments with PPO patients than leaving chairs empty.
Same insurance plan, completely different answer.
How Many Patients Does the Plan Actually Send You?
This one seems obvious, but I’d want the real number.
Not:
“We have 700 Delta patients.”
That doesn’t tell me what Delta is currently doing for the practice.
I’d want to know:
How many new patients came into the practice specifically because you participate with that plan over the last 12 months?
If you’re giving up $150,000 annually in contractual adjustments and the plan is sending you a large number of quality new patients, that’s one conversation.
If it’s sending you almost nobody, that’s another.
You are essentially paying for access to that patient population through reduced fees.
I’d want to know what you're getting for it.
Don’t Forget What It Costs to Deal With the Plan
Write-offs aren’t the only cost.
Someone verifies benefits.
Someone submits claims.
Someone follows up.
Someone handles denials.
Someone resubmits claims.
Someone explains to patients why their insurance didn’t pay what they expected.
Someone sits on hold.
All of that takes time.
And your team’s time costs you money.
Some plans may be considerably more expensive administratively than others.
I’d include that in the equation too.
Now Ask the Question That Makes Everyone Nervous
What happens if we leave?
Let’s say 600 active patients are associated with the plan.
You’re not going to lose all 600.
You’re probably not going to keep all 600 either.
So model it.
What happens if 30% leave? What happens if 50% leave? What happens if 70% leave?
For the patients who stay, what happens when you’re collecting closer to your normal fees?
For the patients who leave, how much production disappears?
How much capacity opens?
And what are you realistically going to do with that capacity?
That’s the part I wouldn’t gloss over.
It’s easy to say:
“We’ll replace them with fee-for-service patients.”
Okay.
How are you going to get those patients?
This Is Where Your Marketing Position Really Matters
Before leaving a significant plan, you’d want to know how strong the practice is without insurance driving the decision.
How visible are you online?
How strong are your reviews?
Do patients specifically seek out the doctor?
Does your website give someone a compelling reason to choose you?
Do you offer services patients actively search for?
Are existing patients referring friends and family?
Does the practice have a strong reputation in the community?
In other words:
Would patients still have a reason to choose you if you weren’t on their insurance list?
If the answer is yes, you have more flexibility.
If most patients are choosing the practice because you accept their plan, I’d be much more cautious.
Here's What I’d Want on One Page
Before making the decision, I’d want a simple analysis for each plan:
What the plan currently produces
Total active patients
New patients generated in the last 12 months
Production at full fees
Actual collections
Contractual adjustments
Patient-paid production
Non-covered and elective treatment
Average production per patient
Hygiene visits
Doctor appointments
Administrative burden
What happens if you leave
Estimated percentage of patients retained
Estimated revenue retained
Additional revenue from higher fees
Revenue lost from patients who leave
Capacity created
Ability to fill that capacity
Expected marketing cost to replace lost patients
Then I’d run several scenarios.
Best case. Reasonable case. Worst case.
Now you have something you can actually make a decision from.
There’s No Trophy for Dropping Insurance
I think this gets lost sometimes.
Going fee-for-service isn’t automatically a better business model.
Neither is staying in-network.
One practice may become dramatically more profitable by dropping its worst PPO.
Another could create a financial mess doing exactly the same thing.
You may discover that one plan should go immediately.
Another is actually pretty profitable.
And a third isn’t great, but it’s feeding enough valuable patients into the practice that it makes sense to keep it for now.
That’s why I wouldn’t make this decision based on what another dentist did.
And I definitely wouldn’t make it because you’re angry about a reimbursement check you opened Tuesday morning.
Run the numbers.
Look beyond the reimbursement.
Look at the patients.
Look at the dentistry they’re buying.
Look at the families and referrals they generate.
Look at the capacity they’re consuming.
Look at what it costs you to participate.
Then look at what realistically happens if they leave.
You may still decide to drop the plan.
But you’ll know exactly why you’re doing it.
If you're considering dropping a plan and aren’t sure what the numbers are really telling you, let’s have a conversation before you make the decision.
Schedule here.